Sunday, January 17, 2010

Congrats 'Punter'. But...

Its known to most of you by now that Ricky 'Punter' Ponting, captain of the Australian national cricket team was recently named the "Player of the decade" by a panel of judges in a poll conducted by ESPN CricInfo. Its pretty clear from the title of this post as to what I want to put-forth. But first things first; the Australian skipper is among the best modern day batsmen and we must congratulate or appreciate his achievements including the recently conferred honor. He has been scoring runs all around the world barring the sub-continent which perhaps is a lone blot on his career graph that includes some mind-numbing highs. I am sure he will continue to do so in the future until the day he hangs-up his bat & boots. Ponting brings a certain aggression to his game like any other Australian, and scores his runs at a blistering pace and when on song, he is among the most destructive batsmen to bowl at. He amassed 19000 International runs in the last decade (incl. Tests, ODIs & T-20s) and that is a staggering achievement.

Incidentally, this is one of the yardsticks used to crown him the player of the decade. And it is this statistic that I base my contradictions on. While I'd like to give the credit where it is due, I also would like to point out, that if ever there was a formidable bowling attack in the last decade it was Australia's. A few truly remarkable individuals like Makhaya Ntini, Dale Steyn, Muttaih Muralidharan did shine, but as a unit, no International cricket team had an attack that came close to the Aussies'. And this is precisely the advantage Ricky Ponting enjoyed in the last decade. As I mentioned earlier, Ponting scored runs all over the world except in the sub-continent. His record against the likes of India, Pakistan & Sri-lanka when touring these countries is abysmal to say the least. Especially when you compare it against the very high standards he set while playing in other countries. Time and again, he was found wanting while facing up to genuine/World-class spin bowling. Our very own Bhajji had Ponting as his bunny each time the Tasmanian batsmen set out to bat in India. Muttaih Muralidharan has also enjoyed considerable success against him whenever they logged-heads. But consider this, Murali chose to sit out of most of the Australia-Srilanka encounters thanks to a certain Mr. Darreyl Hair and his pestering of the former.

Lets now consider another angle to this debate. The mental state of players, while playing for their team & nation at an international stage. I doubt if Ponting, who hails from the most dominant, most intimidating team in the world, boasting perhaps the strongest bowling attack and featuring some of the most destructive batters in the world, ever had to worry too much about his team's standing in any match be it an ODI, a test or a T-20. I will be really interested in finding out how many times Ponting would have stepped out to bat with Australian team in dire-straits or the balance of the match hinging on his wicket or how many runs he scores or most importantly with a burden of anticipations of a legion of fans. I am sure that those situations were a rarity in the life and career of the Australian. For that matter very few Australians would have ever had to play in such pressure cooker scenarios. That meant most of the time, Punter could walk out and play and pace his innings at his own will and this is a luxury only he could afford with the virtue of being an Australian and belonging to a team with most of no. of match winners in its wings.

Consider all this and now think again, was he the best player of the past decade. Or did the panel overlook other worthy winners like a certain 'little-big man' who scored close to 16000 runs in International cricket in the same period*, facing up to bowlers including the Australian legends like Glenn McGrath, Shane Warne. Didn't the panelists over look a mercurial left-handed batting legend hailing from the Carribean, a world-class all rounder from a diamond-rich nation & even the two bowling legends mentioned above who belong to the same country as Punter does. Well it is now for the others to decide the worthiness of Ricky 'Punter' Ponting against all those others who made it to the top-ten, but somehow weren't previliged enough to have been conferred the award in question.

Adios-amigo people!!!

*A little math to further substantiate my point; The 16000 runs mentioned above is 3000 short of Ponting's 19000 runs over a period of 10 years, i.e., 300 runs a year by average. I wonder how significant can this 300 runs in two forms of the game put together be.